One kills more germs than the other – Soap Works Better
The main difference between sanitisers and disinfectants is that sanitisers reduce the number of germs on a surface whereas disinfectants kill most of them.
Sanitisers usually work faster than disinfectants, which can take up to 10 minutes to kill germs. The name hand “sanitiser” is a misnomer since its main germ-fighting ingredient is alcohol, which is a disinfectant.
This article was medically reviewed by Graham Snyder, MD, MS, who is the medical director for the Infection Prevention and Hospital Epidemiology branch at University of Pittsburgh Medical Centre. The words sanitising and disinfecting are often used interchangeably but there are important differences between them. And it’s fair to say this is the time to understand what’s actually in your cleaning cupboard.
The main difference comes down to this: “While sanitising reduces the amount of bacteria, viruses, and other microbes on a surface, disinfectants kill almost all of them,” says Alexander Aiken, MB, of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
“That’s because disinfectants include chemicals like hydrogen peroxide that decontaminate a surface or object by producing destructive free radicals that attack cell components,” says Stephanie Dancer, consultant microbiologist and Professor of Microbiology at Edinburgh Napier University, Scotland.
Sanitisers on the other hand, like chlorine and QUAT (quaternary ammonium compounds) based sanitisers, simply reduce the number of germs on a surface. This may not kill them, but it can still help prevent the spread of illness. Because for each disease, there’s a certain number of germs -called the dose of exposure – you need to contract in order to become sick. So by lowering the total number of germs on a surface or object, sanitisers help reduce the risk of infection.
“Sanitisers and disinfectants also differ in how long they take to work, known as dwell time. Sanitisers can work almost immediately whereas the chemicals in disinfectants take up to 10 minutes to kill germs,” Aiken says. That’s why it’s important to follow the directions on the product
label for effective use.
Clean and then disinfect your surfaces
Studies suggest that SARS-CoV-2 may remain infectious on surfaces for hours to days depending on the type of surface. According to The Centres for Disease Control and Prevention, best practice to prevent the spread of
Covid-19 in households and community settings is to first clean visibly dirty surfaces and then disinfect them. Cleaning can refer to simply wiping it down with a cloth or sanitising it.
For more information, check out our detailed guide on how to disinfect every room in your house.
“The key areas to address are surfaces that are shared by family members and those that come in close contact with bodily fluid. If your windows are dirty, they aren’t a big concern to your health but a doorknob touched after a sneeze can be,” says Michael G. Schmidt, PhD, professor of microbiology at the Medical University of South Carolina and chair of the American Society of Microbiology’s Council on Microbial Sciences.
Also, here’s a guide on the best disinfecting cleaners in 2020 and you can find a full list of disinfectants effective against the COVID-19 virus on The United States Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) website. The EPA emphasises the importance of following the label directions for safe, effective use.
What about hand sanitiser?
The main active ingredient in hand sanitisers is alcohol, which is a surface disinfectant. Therefore, the name hand “sanitiser” is a bit of a misnomer because it’s technically a disinfectant.
While hand sanitiser is effective against SARS-CoV-2, washing your hands with soapy water – which is neither a disinfectant nor sanitiser – is considered best practice for protection against the coronavirus and other germs, according to the CDC. That’s because soap and water kill SARS-CoV-2 by dissolving the virus’s protective outer membrane.
Hand sanitiser is especially less effective if your hands are visibly dirty or have food on them because the proteins and fats in food tend to reduce alcohol’s germ-killing power. This is one of the main reasons soap and water are still favoured in the food industry.